| Year | For | Winner(s) | Defeated in final |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2019 | AEW World championship | Chris Jerihco | "Hangman" Adam Page |
| 2019 | AEW Women's championship | Riho | Nyla Rose |
| 2019 | AEW Tagteam championship | SoCal Uncensored | Lucha Brothers |
| 2020 | TNT championship | Cody | Lance Archer |
| 2022 | TBS championship | Jade Cargill | Ruby Soho |
| 2022 | All-Atlantic championship | Malakai Black | Pac, Miro, Clark Connors |
| 2022 | AEW Trios championship | The Elite | Dark Order |
| 2022 | AEW World championship | Jon Moxley | Bryan Danielson |
| 2023 | Continental championship | Eddie Kingston | Jon Moxley |
| 2024 | AEW Tagteam championship | Young Bucks | FTR |
| 2024 | Continental championship | Kazuchika Okada | Will Ospreay |
| Year | Winner | Dynamite Diamond Battle Royal Finalist |
|---|---|---|
| 2019 | MJF | "Hangman" Adam Page |
| 2020 | MJF | Orange Cassidy |
| 2021 | MJF | Dante Martin |
| 2022 | MJF | Ricky Starks |
| 2023 | MJF | Juice Robinson |
| 2024 | Adam Cole | Kyle O'Reilly |
Note: For the 2024 competition, the format changed into the winner (Adam Cole) battling the diamond ring holder (MJF) at the Worlds End PPV.
| Year | Winners | Defeated in final |
|---|---|---|
| 2020 | Ivelisse & Diamanté | Nightmare Sisters |